Picton Pizzeria returns to its humble beginnings



There’s a new chief behind the counter and what was old is new again in downtown Picton.

Call it a rebirth, call it Picton Pizzeria 2.0 but whatever you do, if you like pizza made in the traditional Montreal style, just call Andrew Stellatos and Megan Hutton at the familiar spot.

Familiar to those of us that can remember wandering into the Picton Pizzeria in the mid-1980’s long before a major franchise restaurant ever dreamed of setting up a location in Prince Edward County, the engaged couple have brought Picton Pizzeria back to life at its original location at the corner of Main and Bowery streets.

Angelo Stellatos opened the original restaurant in Nov. 1980 and spent about two decades in the location before transitioning to a larger, sit-down family dining room style restaurant a kilometre or two west on Main st. called Angelo’s in the late 1990’s.

After another two decades or so and Stellatos and Hutton have returned the family business to a familiar haunt much to the delight of valued customers and those in the crowd that appreciate the nuanced way in which Picton Pizzeria feels like it never left.

Stellatos feels exactly that way as he flips some dough on a snowy Tuesday afternoon.

Andrew Stellatos flips some dough. (Jason Parks/Gazette Staff)

“We spent 20 years here, we were 20 years down the street, hopefully we will be back here for another 20 years,” he said with a laugh.

The renaissance of the pizzeria at its former location wasn’t really anything Stellatos or Hutton had planned.

With his parents looking to retire and exit the business, the operation was scaled down to a take out restaurant and it was eventually arrived at that Andrew would take over the family business.

“Half of me was thinking about going back to school but the other half of me liked doing this and it was in my blood,” he said. “The lease was coming due at the old restaurant and we started to look around and (building owner) Al Van Solen said ‘Why don’t you come down and have a look at the old place?’ It still had the hole for the old chimney and all of a sudden, anything seemed possible.”

“We honestly had no intention of doing this and coming back here. No conscious intent at all. But we looked at it and looked at each other and we said can’t pass this up,” he added.

And those of us who grew up on Picton Pizzeria pizza from the old (or new, depending on your point of view) location feel as though time has reversed in some sort of magical and delicious way.

“The wierd thing is that it feels like we never left and we’ve been here for years,” he added.

After preparations were undertaken and the restaurant was refashioned with the original concept but with a more modern tract, it was finally opened in mid-December.

To an immediate response.

“We are ecstatic, I never imagined it all coming together like this. We were so busy and if it weren’t for our customers being so understanding, we would have lost our minds,” Stellatos said. “We took the paper off the windows on opening day and literally had two long time customers ready to walk in and place an order.”

Running out of dough was an unfortunate but regular occurrence as Picton Pizzaeria tried to gauge its impact and budget accrodingly.

Even staffing compliments needed to be built up drastically as the demand immeidately out wieghed supply.

“We had no idea what the response was going to be and it was overwhelming right from the start,” Megan Hutton added. “It was just incredible how people would pour in to place an order, checking things out and talk about the old days.”

And it’s not only friends or valued customers that have returned to say hello.

Or even lend a hand.

In the first week of renewed operations, former employee Mark Graham stopped by with his daughter Alice to see the recreation of the site of one of his first places of employment.

“They were here for slices and we were swamped which has been kind of an ongoing trend right from the first day,” Stellatos said. “Mark and Alice had their pizza, came back at 3:30 and put in a shift just to help us with the supper orders.”

Long time friends that hadn’t darkened the doorstep of the restaurant since the old days popped by including a person from Halifax who was travelling on the 401, heard Picton Pizzeria had reopened at its former location and simply had to make a detour in order to dive into a pie.

Tokens of appreciation and nostalgia have appeared and humbled Stellatos in a emotional sense.

‘One day a cardboard package arrived that I wasn’t expecting and I opened it up and I had to compose myself pretty quickly.

Andrew Stellatos shows of a 1994 snapshot of himself and former employee Mark Graham. (Jason Parks/Gazette Staff)

Rob Chu, a boyhood friend of Stellatos and whose family owned the Golden Inn at the same time Picton Pizzeria was in its first hey day, sent a number of black Picton Pizzeria t shirts for the staff.

“I’m trying so hard not to break down. He sends me these right out of the blue and I’m totally in awe,” said Stellatos.

The redesigned eatery complete with artifacts, pizza peels, photographs and newspaper clippings on the wall have been well received by so many customers.

Even the green, white and red sign that was installed over top of the original restaurant in 1984 is a fixture inside the renovated establishment.

Stellatos said many visitors have told him walking into Picton Pizzeria feels like a homecoming and, for him, flipping dough and baking pizzas doesn’t even feel like a job right now.

“I didn’t realize it meant so much to so many people. It always meant so much to me and my brothers and my family but everyday someone is coming in and making a comment about how great it is to see us back here.

A nephew of the late Ivan Stringer came in and talked about coming back to the his uncle’s old haunt and that the only thing missing is Ivan

Stellatos told him to check again and hanging on the back wall was a picture of Ivan, arm-in-arm with his dear friend the late Terry Hineman in a team photo of the old Picton Pizza hockey team.

“He’d never seen the photo and we both had a moment,” Stellatos said.

The one question on this reporter’s mind and probably everyone else’s is what family patriarch Angelo thinks about the return of Picton Pizzeria

Son Andrew regretfully reports that Angelo can’t quite comprehend the business has returned to its roots where his father first laid his hands in the dough.

Angelo spends his days at HJ McFarland Home where, when he has a good day, he motors around the dining room and asks fellow residents and staff about their orders and if the service is ok and if the food was tasty.

“He liked it up at Angelo’s for sure but I know he missed the interaction with the guests he was able to have at this location. Socially, he missed meeting with everyone and talking with them so he did miss this location for sure,” Andrew added.

Like so many Greek immigrants who value and understood the bond of family, that trait has been ingrained in future generations.

“Dad is big on family, about working together and staying close,” Andrew said. “He also taught us about seeing the customers as friends and now see how and why he was so dedicated to the people who would come here to eat. Through time and bringing back Picton Pizzeria, it’s brought it completely full circle and I have that appreciation for what he built and what he went through to make it all happen.”
Stellatos has also picked up a new to him but re-used nickname.

“It’s funny, I never heard anyone call my dad ‘Chief’ when I was younger but when I started to hang around the restaurant, everybody would call him Chief and I haven’t heard it since.But since we’ve opened, I’ve had no less than a dozen people say “Thanks, Chief”

“I guess I’m the new Chief,” he added with a laugh