Prince Edward County’s Newspaper of Record
May 18, 2024
15° Cloudy

Rail transport a smarter, cleaner choice for Omicore

In response to your article in the June 1, 2023 edition of the Picton Gazette:

“BOQ MP says Terminals could be part of Green Transport Strategy”

Mr. Williams contends that transporting the Cathode Active Material (CAM) that will be produced at the Omicore plant north of Millhaven using Picton Terminals is the most environmentally friendly option when compared to road or rail. This simply is not true when you look at the numbers.

Both the Omicore and the St. Thomas VW EV battery sites are served by rail. Using the figures (provided by Dr. Mabee in your article) that trucks produce 20x more ghg per km than ship and that rail produces 4x the ghg per km, here’s an analysis that takes into account that, under the marine option, the containers would need to be trucked at each end of the ship’s route.
Hamilton is the closest container port to St. Thomas.
Distance Impact Total
km units/km Impact
Hamilton to St. Thomas (truck) 140 20 2800
Millhaven to Picton (truck) 65 20 1300
Picton to Hamilton (ship) 280 1 280
4380
Millhaven to St. Thomas (rail) 430 4 1720
Rail is 2.5 times better.

Even if the containers were moved by rail from Hamilton to St. Thomas (making the first option above rail, truck, ship), the rail-only option is still significantly better and much simpler. In any case, I suspect Omicore will select their shipping option based on more than just ghg emissions.

I find it shocking that a Member of Parliament would promote the interests of a company which has ignored both Provincial and Federal environmental orders and is currently before the court for defiance of County by-laws. I also point out that CAM is toxic. A spill would be a disaster for Picton’s water supply.

Finally, has anyone actually spoken to Omicore about their transportation plans? I suspect Mr. Williams has not. I hope Council is not persuaded by this bogus proposal when they consider this issue.
Dave Sutherland
Lake-on-the-Mountian
This text is from the Volume 193 No. 24 edition of The Picton Gazette
Spread the Word

Keep in Touch

Share your email address with us to receive our weekly newsletter and exclusive content direct to your inbox.

We will not share your email without your permission.

Advertisement

Sitemap

Canada’s oldest weekly newspaper
© 2024 The Picton Gazette
Since 1830
Funded by the Government of Canada
Ontario Community Newspapers Association